Can we cease pretending that QB wins are a significant statistic?

Sports activities are bizarre. This can be the one world the place you possibly can construct a story and inform it again and again whereas nobody blinks an eye fixed.

There are a lot of fools I do not allow you to disturb. Issues like “working a fallacious case value this crew a sport.” OK, to be sincere, I let that have an effect on me infrequently. From time to time I imply nearly each week. Nonetheless, there’s one narrative that’s by far the worst of all. It is one which, frankly, does not make logical sense and will be actually harmful.

Pay attention, received it. Let me begin by saying that I do know the quarterback is crucial place. playmaker could make the distinction between an excellent crew and a nasty crew, as can an excellent defender or an excellent left sort out. We actually noticed the NFL groups win Super Bowl with guys whose greatest function is an lively pulse. Howdy, Tren Diver. In any case, immediately I need to cowl the principle the reason why we simply have to cease giving quarterbacks a win / lose report.


Okay gang, silly soccer to the naked bones, okay? The soccer crew consists of 53 gamers and consists of three phases. Each unit has a job.

First you may have your offense. They need to work collectively as a unit to advance down the sector and rating factors. The quarterback should have gamers who’re capable of block lengthy sufficient to develop, catchers working the proper routes and catching passes, or a quarterback by which to go the ball.

Then we now have protection and particular groups. The protection is chargeable for preserving the factors off the board, and particular groups are chargeable for putting the crew in affordable beginning positions.

It is simply numbers in the mean time. There are three items in soccer and the quarterback performs solely considered one of them. Why will we solely blame one participant for shedding? Quarterback, like Jonathan Moxon in Varsity Bluesit’s only one man. It actually simply cannot do its job with out somebody to dam, seize, or run away.

There are such a lot of examples that this isn’t true

In 2020, Alvin Kamara had a Madden-on-easy sport in opposition to the Vikings when he was working for six touchdowns. In the identical sport, Drew Brees made 311 yards and two steals. Brees deserved a victory.

In 2012, Matt Ryan threw 301 yards and 5 steals in opposition to the Cardinals and the Falcons continued to win 23-19 as Matt Bryant scored three massive objectives from the sector, the protection ran again house and Michael Turner scored. Matt Ryan was thought of the winner of this sport.

Ryan Lindley as soon as threw at 104 yards and intercepted in a 38-10 win in opposition to Lions. Why is Lindley credited with the victory if he simply existed for 4 quarters?

It isn’t simply winnings. There may be additionally an issue with losses. In 2011 Matthew Stafford threw 520 yards and 5 touchdowns in opposition to Packersand the Lions nonetheless misplaced that sport as a result of Matt Flynn made a soccer counterpart Mario will step on the super mushroom and tossed for six touchdowns. It may well’t be Matthew Stafford’s fault that the Lions misplaced this sport.

Patrick Mahomes took six touchdowns in opposition to Aries in 2018 and the Chiefs nonetheless misplaced because the protection allowed 54 factors. What extra are you able to ask these playmakers to assist their groups win? Why would they be in charge for the losses?

These are usually not simply chosen concepts. There might be increasingly of this kind of factor yearly.

Why is that this an issue?

This can be a drawback for 3 causes. First, as a result of franchises base their groups’ success so closely on playmakers that they have an inclination to disregard all the pieces else.

Darnold himself is an ideal instance of this. Darnold is not pretty much as good as we all know him, however he is not the worst both. Darnold is a basic instance of why pondering that the quarterback will resolve all of your issues successfully provides one other drawback.

The Jets took Darnold with a 3rd choose in 2018 after which did nothing to assist him succeed. Throughout his three-year tenure with the Jets, the crew’s protection was fourth, seventeenth and seventh within the league by factors awarded. His working match completed twenty sixth, thirty first and twenty third on the pitch with Robby Anderson and Jamison Crowder being his greatest receivers on the time – neither of them had been capable of get near 1000 yards or rating greater than six touchdowns in a single match. season. Lastly, he had three completely different coaches throughout this time.

All of that is going fallacious with Darnold, and he is the one in charge. Not the Jets, who did not develop him nicely sufficient, did not encompass him with gamers who helped him succeed and altered coaches thrice in three years.

It occurs to a unique man or different guys yearly. A participant with potential is kicked out by a crew that has performed nothing to assist him, and the league and followers think about him a nasty product though he didn’t do it himself. No quarterback does this, though it might seem like doing it at instances.

There are additionally groups that purchase quarterbacks based mostly on good efficiency. Matt Flynn made almost $ 20 million from the Lions sport with six touchdowns as a result of the CEOs believed he may repeat the efficiency.

Virtually each time this occurs, it places apart a younger quarterback who might be a future starter if correctly drawn.

Lastly, the stress that comes with it places the playmakers ready the place they really feel they should play by accidents to remain on the pitch and assist their crew win. Should you’re a quarterback and get concussions throughout a four-game loss streak, followers and the franchise will clearly see that you’re a drawback. That is the type of factor that may make a participant lie about being injured as a way to keep on the pitch, chase victory and hold his job.

Playmakers do not win and lose matches alone, so let’s cease performing as if playmaker wins and losses are stats that matter.

Leave a Comment